CAUSES AND CONSEQUENCES OF DISC DETERIORATION: PRACTICAL EXAMPLES

 

DETERIORATION DUE TO FITTING THE DISC

1. INCORRECT TIGHTENING

Description of defect: Formation of cracks on the carrier surface in contact with the hub. This is due to incorrect tightening during fitting. The tightening sequence has not been followed and torque is insufficient. Failure to follow the recommended sequence and tightening torque can cause distortion of the carrier mounting surface even when there are no visible cracks.

Consequences: Distortion of the carrier mounting surface causes vibrations that can be felt immediately after fitting when the brake pedal is pressed.

Advice: Fit another disc, following the recommended sequence and tightening torque.

 

 

 

 

 

 

2. FAILURE TO OBSERVE THE RECOMMENDED TIGHTENING TORQUE

Description of the defect: The carrier mounting surface breaks away from the rest of the disc. There are clear signs of excessive tightening, above all in the area of the two fixing holes. This is evidence of a failure to observe the recommended torque and sequence during tightening.

Consequences: Pronounced rasping noises and absence of braking torque.

Advice: Fit another disc, following the recommended sequence and tightening torque.

3. EXCESSIVE TIGHTENING OF THE POSITIONING BOLT

Description of the defect: The carrier mounting surface can easily distort when the disc positioning bolt is tightened too much. This excessive tightening can cause the mounting surface to break as can be seen in the photo.

Consequences: Run outing cannot be kept within an acceptable tolerance. Heavy vibrations occur during the very first kilometres following installation.

Advice: Tightening bolts are only intended to ensure that discs are positioned correctly. Do not tighten them excessively.

 

 

 

 

 

 

4. FITTING A DISC THAT DOES NOT CORRESPOND TO THE CAR

Description of the defect: Formation of cracks on the carrier mounting surface. Signs of a poor match between the diameter of the disc centring and that of the hub.

Consequences: Disc contact with the wheel hub is incorrect. This defective installation will immediately cause vibrations due to excessive run outing.

Advice: Check catalogues to determine the correct disc reference: model, year of manufacture. Never force discs when fitting.

5. INCORRECT ASSEMBLY OF THE CALIPER BODY ON THE AXLE

Description of defect: The braking surfaces have broken away from the hub. Asymmetrical braking surface wear can be noted: the central area of the external surface in respect of the vehicle and the outer edge of the internal surface. In this case mechanical stress has caused the disc to break and the braking surfaces have come away.

Consequences: The impact of this breakage can be felt when braking. Very loud rasping noises. Safety is compromised.

Advice: Before fitting new discs check the alignment and assembly of the caliper body on the axle.

 

 

 


6. INCORRECT TIGHTENING OF THE DISC AND
HUB BEARINGS

Description of defect: An exaggerated tightening torque knocks the bottom out of the bearing seat.

Consequences: Braking system functioning is compromised because of disc instability relative to the bearings. Strong vibrations are felt right from the first braking action.

Advice: Replace the hub, bearings and disc. Apply correct tightening torque when installing.

7. DIRTY HUB

Description of defect: The hub surface was not cleaned when the disc was fitted: presence of rust or dirt. Tightening against this unsuitable surface causes the new disc to run out excessively.

Consequences:  This error during installation causes the onset of vibrations after a few hundred or thousand braking actions, vibrations that increase with the distance travelled. Uneven disc wear as a result of the pads causes DTV to increase - this is the origin of the vibrations - and noise (see section 3.3.3).

Advice: Clean contact surfaces very carefully. Check disc run out after installation.

 

 

 

8. PRONOUNCED WHEEL HUB RUN OUT

Description of defect: Excessive hub run out causes the braking surfaces to wear as they are not parallel to the plane of the disc. Evidence of localised overheating is indicated by the darker colour of the worn areas. This is due to an alternating rubbing action of the disc and pads as a result of pronounced wheel hub run out.

Consequences: Vibrations can be felt right from the start and progressively increase. Onset of loud noises.

Advice: Check the wheel hub run out and ensure that this falls within the tolerance specified in the disc installation instructions.

 

 

 







 

 

 

DETERIORATION DUE TO USE

1. NO RUNNING IN

Description of defect: Disc shows colouring of varying intensity and shades (blue, violet, golden), mainly visible in the cooling areas (groove and carrier interior).

Consequences: Initial slight vibrations that progressively increase. Overheating of this type alters the mechanical characteristics of the cast iron in as much as there is a change in structure due to the formation of cementite (Fe3C).

Advice: Always advise users to observe a running in period. Brake only moderately and briefly during the first 200-300 kilometres over a mixed itinerary. Avoid prolonged pad to disc contact.


2. INTENSIVE USE

Description of defect: Disc thickness is considerably less than the recommended minimum thickness (4 mm less in total). Cracks are evident. Heat spots are visible in areas corresponding to the ventilation blades. This is advance warning that other cracks will form.

Consequences: Noises, vibrations.

Advice: This situation is typical of that found on certain sports vehicles which are subjected to an intensive and excessive use on the road.

 

 

 

EXCESSIVE WEAR

1. EXCEEDING THE LIMIT

Description of defect: The thickness of the braking surfaces measured using a micrometer is less than the recommended minimum thickness etched on the outer disc rim or on the carrier.

Consequences: Performance and comfort decreases.

Advice: Check state of disc wear periodically. The disc should be replaced after every two or three pad changes. Pads must be changed every time discs are replaced.

 

 

 

2. EXCESSIVE WEAR WITH CRACKS

Description of defect:

a) disc

The minimum thickness indicated on the outer rim of the disc has been exceeded by more than 1 mm. Furthermore, the disc has been subjected to excessive operating temperatures as a result of the reduced braking surface thickness. This causes cracks of a thermal origin.

b) pads

More marked wear can be noted in the central area of the disc whereas the area in correspondence with the pads is less worn. This can be attributed to the presence of hard points in the friction material, an indication that the production mixture was not homogeneous. It can also indicate poor functioning of the caliper.

Consequences: Distortion caused by vibrations during braking. In the long run cracks may form that can lead to disc breakage.

Advice: Periodically check disc wear. The disc must be replaced every two or three pad changes.

 

 

 



 

 

 


3. APPEARANCE OF CRACKS

Description of defect: The disc has been subjected to excessive operating temperatures: in the outer area of the braking surface there are evident signs of overheating. High operating temperatures lead to the appearance of cracks.

Consequences: Distortion and pad "bouncing" when hot that causes vibrations during braking. With time, cracks form and the disc may break.

Advice: The worn disc must be replaced. Check the state of wear periodically.

4. EXCESSIVE WEAR AND PADS COMPLETELY WORN DOWN

Description of defect: The disc is extremely worn and has been damaged by the metal pad support, the friction material of which has completely disappeared. The thickness of this disc when new was 7 mm, measured now it is 3.5 mm compared to a recommended minimum thickness of 5 mm.

Consequences: Very loud noises, very long braking distances, caliper functioning is critical.

Advice: Replace pads when they reach wear limits. Check out the pad wear warning indicator circuit.

 

 

 

5. BREAKAGE DUE TO EXCESSIVE WEAR

Description of defect: Braking surfaces show evident signs of overheating due to the considerably reduced mass of the worn disc. This situation has caused the braking surfaces to break away from the hub.

Consequences: Violent impact during braking. A very strong rasping noise when braking. Possible safety problem.

Advice: Always check the disc thickness every time the pads are replaced. Replace the disc before it reaches its wear limit.

 

 

 

 

 

 

6. EXCESSIVE PAD WEAR AND MOVEMENT OF THE SUPPORT

Description of defect: Disc thickness less than the limit value. The disc has been worn by the pad support as friction material is completely absent. The metal support plate has come out of its seat in the caliper and has almost entirely cut the disc brake surface from the carrier. The braking surfaces are near to breaking away from the carrier.

Consequences: Rasping noises, loss of efficiency (considerable brake pedal slack), possible rubbing between the disc and caliper, thrust of the caliper is not symmetrical.

Advice: Check and, if necessary, repair the caliper. Replace the discs and pads.

DETERIORATION DUE TO OTHER BRAKING SYSTEM COMPONENTS

1. UNEVEN WEAR OF VARIOUS PARTS

Description of defect: A braking surface of one of the discs is in contact with the metal pad support. Examining the pads it is noted that wear is uneven due to blocking of the caliper (the pads on the other caliper are in perfect condition).

Consequences: The caliper's two pads are completely worn down with consequent onset of noises and vibrations, the brake pedal has to be depressed completely. Braking distance is very long.

Advice: Check, repair or replace the caliper. Replace all discs and pads.

 

 

 

2. VITRIFIED DISC

Description of defect: Presence of a very fine deposit of friction material on the disc surface which now has a shiny finish (corrosion has then caused the detachment of part of this layer).

Consequences: Loss of braking efficiency, braking distances too long. The pedal is very stiff but with no braking action.

Advice: Replace discs and pads. Use high, original, quality pads.

 

 

 

 

 

 

3. UNEVEN BRAKING SURFACE WEAR

Description of defect: The two pads were not positioned in the same manner with respect to the disc. Wear has not been the same for both surfaces. Heat spots can be noted at the centre of the braking surface due to high thermal exposure. The caliper and/or the pads were not fitted properly.

Consequences: Gradual onset of vibrations due to the heat spots. Possible appearance of cracks.

Advice: Check and, if necessary, repair the calipers. Check the pad model and friction material quality.

4. DEEP GROOVES AND SCORING

Description of defect: Deep scores caused by penetration of foreign bodies between pads and disc can be noted. This can be due to unsuitable pad material or the presence of badly distributed abrasives in the mixture.

Consequences: Very unpleasant noise both during braking and when travelling. Diminished efficiency as a result of the reduced contact surface between disc and pads.

Advice: Replace discs and pads.

 

 

 

5. FRICTION MATERIAL DEPOSITS

Description of defect: The braking surfaces are completely covered by very dark spots. These spots are due to deposits of pad friction material. This causes overheating which in turn leads to a transformation of the cast iron with the formation of very hard cementite.

Consequences: Onset of vibrations that become progressively worse.

Advice: Only install friction material that is suited to the brake and vehicle.

 

 

 



6. BRAKING SURFACES PARTLY WORN BY THE PADS

Description of defect: The braking surface only shows wear in the outer area. The inner area never comes into contact with the pads as indicated by the presence of corrosion (rust). This situation could be caused by:

     incorrect installation of the caliper and hence the pad which does not make full contact with the disc

     loss of part of the friction material

     fitting of wrong pads

Consequences: Reduced braking torque. Increase in operating temperature as the surface on which the pad works is reduced (by about 50% in this example) compared to its normal working surface. There is a risk of localised overheating and therefore the onset of hot judder-type vibrations. Moreover, reduced system efficiency leads to high stress levels and therefore rapid and/or uneven wear (cold judder).

Advice: check the installation and correct functioning of the caliper. Check the fitting and condition of the pads. Check that the pad model is suitable for the particular vehicle.

 

 

 

7. PARTIALLY WORN AND VITRIFIED BRAKING SURFACES

Description of defect: This disc shows a deterioration that is the sum of defects described in 2 and 6 above. In this case the pad only acts on the inner section of the braking surface. High stress has led to overheating, vitrification (deposit) and detachment of friction material.

Consequences: Progressive reduction in efficiency of the system and, when friction material detaches, total inefficiency of the system.

Advice: As for 2 and 6.

 

 

 


8. CURVED PADS

Description of defect: The pads only act on the central section of the braking surface. They may be curved.

Consequences: Reduced braking action with the consequences described in points 6 and 7.

Advice: Check pad planarity and the functioning of the calipers.

 

 

 

CHANGES IN DISC SIZE CHARACTERISTICS

When initial measurements of the fitted disc and successive observation do not give clear answers, it may be useful to analyse disc dimensions further.

Placing the disc on a bench as seen in the illustration, it is possible to measure its dimensions without these being affected by other brake components.

- After cleaning the surface coming into contact with the hub using sandpaper, the disc must be able to rest on the bench bearing without run out. This is done by holding the disc at the extremities of a diameter with the fingers and checking its vertical movement. If the disc is unstable this indicates distortion due to incorrect or excessive tightening.

- With the aid of a DTI Gauge mounted on a fixed base it is possible to measure the disc's production run out, provided that it has not been rectified by the mechanic at the time of fitting. This measurement is carried out by resting the DTI Gauge against the external or internal edge of the disc where the pads have not worn the braking surfaces. If the run out value measured is greater than 0.05 mm it means that the disc originally had a marked run out, a certain cause of vibration. If the value is less, then the acquired run out is measured by placing the point of the DTI Gauge at the centre of the braking surface: if it is beyond the tolerance this indicates incorrect installation that causes vibrations after a few thousand kilometres (cold judder due to a DTV increase).

- Lastly, when travelling, it is possible to determine if vibrations are caused by the front discs or the rear drums. Proceeding at low speed, pull lightly on the handbrake: if there are vibrations the problem concerns the rear drums (check and, if necessary, replace them).

BREMBO ADVICE TO USERS

01 -  Braking style - just like driving style - must always be adapted to climatic conditions and the state of road and traffic.

02 -  Braking distance not only depends on braking system efficiency but also on the conditions of tyres and suspension.

03 -  Optimal braking within a limited distance is which provides maximum deceleration without locking the wheels, the consequences of which would be the loss of vehicle stability and an increase in braking distance.

04 -  In the case of long downhill stretches it is advisable to use the engine brake and above all not to switch off the engine. After a brief stop, check pedal efficiency before starting off again.

05 -  When the situation requires a prolonged and continuous use of the braking system, release pressure on the brake pedal from time to time for a brief period.

06 -  After stopping for a long period the first braking actions will be affected by the stop, and also by climatic conditions. A certain number of braking actions should be performed in order to re-establish the full efficiency of the disc-pad unit.

07 -  Ensure that all parts of the braking system function correctly: fluid level, pad and disc wear, rear brake lights, parking brake indicator, etc. Follow the manufacturers instructions as regards replacement of the brake fluid (frequency, quality).

08 -  Periodically check the efficiency of the parking brake by trying to move the vehicle when this brake is on.

09 -  Only use spare parts produced by recognised manufacturers.

10 -  If possible, use a vehicle equipped with a braking control system (ABS, etc.).